I’ve been watching the Bookish/Author community for a while now and I can’t help but notice some trends that are cropping up. Or at least a certain cycle of events that keep circling.
It has become the popular thing to do to draw lines in the sand or find hills to die on. Some of these are in good fun, told in a tone of voice that proves the creator is merely claiming their opinion on something silly.
Things like which Book Boyfriend is the best or which magic system they would prefer to live in. Things like this I have no problem with, they are meant in a joking manner and are both entertaining and fun.
But then there’s the other type of Hill to Die On.
Said with capitol letters.
Things like, First Person POV is the best POV.
Which, hey, if you love First Person and that’s where you go to relax and enjoy a book then hey… You do you! I’m so glad you enjoy those. I do too.
However, there seems to be this trend that says “If you don’t die on this hill with me, then you’re wrong and you’re awful and we’re going to throw bricks at you until you come around to our viewpoint.”
These Hills to Die On are everywhere.
Audiobooks don’t count as real reading!
Em-Dashes mean it was written by AI! (Reminder, this is utterly false and AI learned to write based on all of us authors, using tools we often use, so OF COURSE AI learned how to use the em-dash.)
Clean romance versus spicy romance!
Romantasy is killing literature!
Now… because I am a human being, I have opinions on these things, but I have them with the understanding that my opinions and tastes are going to change as I grow. So, why would I want to die on a hill here?
Further, why would I want to alienate people by deciding to plant my flag on that hill and start shouting it?
Again, when it is all in a joking manner there’s no issue but these days it seems were are hunting for ways to divide ourselves. Instead of a Reading Community that is welcoming, we start congregating in subsects and ganging up on anyone who likes different things.
I’ve watched it get super ugly.
And I can’t help but wonder why.
Why do we do this?
Why can’t we say – Hey! You read? That’s amazing! What are you reading right now?
And then, you know, NOT JUDGE THEM for what they choose to read?
There doesn’t need to be a war here. If someone reads a book you don’t like, why does it matter to you? For the love of God, stop trying to control other people. Their decisions are not up to you.
Yes, you can have an opinion, but don’t cross the line into – You are so stupid for liking that book.
Or
That book is ruining literature by merely existing.
First of all, the hubris on that last accusation is so high that maybe you should take a few moments of genuine self-reflection. Literature existed long before you were born and it’ll survive long after you’re gone. Further, literature is a reflection of the culture and times in which it lives.
I digress.
And I suppose I have found my own Hill to Die On.
Stop the division. Stop finding reasons to hate each other. Stop attacking people who have taken the time to read and stop trying to control people.
You’re allowed your opinions. You can write them in your reviews and give your stars, one through five, but at the end of the day it is nothing more than your opinion. It is not something to foist on other people and demand they agree with you.
We’re beautifully diverse. It’s alright to compromise here. It’s alright to be different. You live, you laugh, you love, you matter. And so does the person sitting next to you.
Happy Reading, everyone.






