This book had great atmosphere. I loved the gaslamp aspects of the setting and the villains were quite hateable very early on. I particularly enjoyed Kell, ostensibly the main character, and was drawn into his tale early on.
What knocked this down to a four star instead of a five star book for me was the OTHER character in the novel – Lila. She just felt so very shallow that I was never really rooting for her. I understand that some of her past was likely deliberately left off the page, that the author may have been distant from all the things that make the girl who she is because she herself was distant from them and didn’t want to confront all that she had been through.
However, I needed her to confront some of it. The constant yearning for another place and wanting to be more than she was and daydreaming about a pirate ship fell flat for me because she never really revealed anything of herself. Sure, she had some moments with Kell where things slipped out, but we were inside her POV and head enough that we – the Reader – deserved to know more.
That said, I recognize this is a ME preference and problem. And perhaps the novel was showcasing a personality who deliberately lived “in the moment” because she chose not to dwell on the things that built her into the thieving, I’m-ok-with-killing-when-I-have-to personality that she is. I could kind of see that perspective on the page, but as a reader I felt I deserved a more blatant confrontation with herself and subsequent understanding afterward.
What knocked this UP to a four was most assuredly Kell. He had all the questions and few of the answers and that drove me forward. I loved how much of an underdog he felt like, and the magic system in general. I loved the dynamic between Kell and his brother, though I have weird feelings about his so-called parents. I’m curious to see what happens next in their story.
Happy Reading, everyone!

